Tilbake
Fulltid (3 - 2)
| 90' |  | 3-2 Brian White Assists: Jared Stroud |
| 89' |  | Aaron Long |
| 81' | | Kyle Duncan |
Luis Mario Díaz Espinoza Derrick Etienne |  | 81' |
| 76' | | Marc Rzatkowski Sean Davis |
| 76' | | Jared Stroud Caden Clark |
| 76' | | Alejandro Fabián Romero Rectte Florian Valot |
3-1 Gyasi Zardes Assists: Derrick Etienne | | 68' |
| 59' | | Brian White Daniel Royer |
| 51' | | Cristian Alfonso Cásseres Cásseres Dru Yearwood |
| 2-1 Darlington Nagbe | | 46' |
| 40' | | Sean Davis |
1-1 Pedro Miguel Martins Santos Straffespark |  | 26' |
| 23' | | 0-1 Caden Clark |
Columbus Crew
New York Red Bulls
1 Eloy Room
11 Gyasi Zardes
25 Harrison Afful
4 Jonathan Mensah
3 Josh Williams
19 Milton Nahuel Valenzuela
6 Darlington Nagbe
8 Jose Artur de Lima Junior
22 Derrick Etienne
10 Lucas Manuel Zelarrayán
7 Pedro Miguel Martins Santos
Substitutes
13 Andrew Tarbell
9 Fanendo Adi
29 Krisztián Németh
12 Luis Mario Díaz Espinoza
21 Aidan Morris
20 Emmanuel Boateng
30 Aboubacar Keita
2 Christopher Cadden
14 Waylon Dwayne Francis Box
6 Kyle Duncan
26 Tim Parker
33 Aaron Long
24 Jason Pendant
16 Dru Yearwood
27 Sean Davis
77 Daniel Royer
37 Caden Clark
22 Florian Valot
18 Ryan Meara
74 Tom Barlow
Substitutes
11 Samuel Tetteh Kotoko
23 Cristian Alfonso Cásseres Cásseres
8 Jared Stroud
10 Alejandro Fabián Romero Rectte
90 Marc Rzatkowski
3 Amro Tarek Abdel Aziz
39 Mandela Egbo
1 David Jensen
42 Brian White